Grand Cayman & No Bake Cookies and Cream Bars

Yesterday we arrived on the third leg of our June trip. After traveling from Miami to Key West to Cape Cod, we are now enjoying eight days of laying on the beach, scuba diving and great food in Grand Cayman. I love this place! Three years ago Andrew and I were married in the Cayman Islands on Seven Mile Beach. With twenty-three good friends and family we celebrated for a full week filled with scuba diving, great food, and fun! We were married at sunset on Seven Mile Beach at the Grand Cayman Beach Suites.

I walked down the aisle to the sound of a steel drum band. We read our handwritten vows to one another as I struggled to remember them thru my tears.

The wedding ceremony was incredible and we couldn’t have asked for a better setting.

After the reception we had cocktails and dinner at the beachside restaurant Hemingways.  The wedding cake was a rum cake with coconut cream filling and a luscious buttercream frosting.

Last night we celebrated our third wedding anniversary at the Grand Old House, a 103 year old plantation house right on the water’s edge over looking the Caribbean Sea. The views from the veranda are absolutely breathtaking. Three years ago we had our rehearsal dinner at the Grand Old House, so when we were thinking of where to have our anniversary dinner there was no question. Andrew ordered the Cayman Turtle Steak Scaloppini with fried avocado rice and a spicy pepper sauce. I ordered the daily fish special of blackened Mahi Mahi, jumbo crab cake and a grilled jumbo shrimp. The food was incredible and the view was just stunning.

Now onto a wonderful and super quick recipe for a crowd pleasing dessert. These No Bake Cookies and Cream Bars are a twist on the classic rice krispies treats. Made with Oreo Cookies instead of Rice Krispies! 🙂

No Bake Cookies and Cream Bars

Printer Friendly Version


  • One 16 oz package of Oreo Cookies
  • 5 cups large marshmallows
  • 4 tablespoons butter


  1. Butter an 8X8 inch baking pan. Line the baking pan with parchment paper letting the paper extend up two sides of the pan and overhang slightly on both ends. Butter paper; set pan aside.
  2. In the bowl of a food processor fitted with the metal blade, pulse Oreos  until ground.
  3. In a large, microwave safe bowl, melt butter and marshmallows in the microwave until puffed, about 1½ – 2 minutes. Stir in ground Oreo Cookies until combined. Transfer to prepared baking pan. Using a piece of wax paper, press mixture evenly into prepared pan.
  4. Let set up for at least 10 minutes. Cut into bars and serve.

Yields: 16 bars

Source: Picky Palate

Have you ever been to Grand Cayman? Did you enjoy it? Do you have any recommendations on what to see and do? How about a few no-miss restaurants? I’d love to hear them! 🙂

This entry was posted in Dessert, Travel and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

78 Responses to Grand Cayman & No Bake Cookies and Cream Bars

  1. Happy anniversary, such great photos!!! Those bars sound easy and delicious!

  2. Congrats on the 3 years! I love looking at wedding pictures and yours are beautiful! These no bake bars look so good….I’ll have to give them a try!

  3. Fabulous photos, looks like such a beautiful wedding!
    And your bars sound quite delicious, how can you go wrong with those ingredients? Have fun, thanks, Chris

  4. Happy 3rd! Lovely photos, I can see why you love the place.

  5. yumtherapy says:

    Wow, your wedding looked amazing! That is so sweet that you are spending your 3rd anniversary there 🙂 I actually went to Grand Cayman last month, but only for a day because I was on a cruise. That was the one place I really wanted to stay for much longer! We managed to fit in an island tour and a snorkeling/Stingray City excursion by the company, Captain Marvin’s. It was great because the staff was very friendly and there were very few other people on the tour with us. If you haven’t done Stingray City yet, you should! It’s basically a sandbar full of stingrays…but they are used to people and will come right up to you. So if you go on one of the stingray excursions, you get to hold stringrays, feed them, and get some really cool pictures of the whole thing 🙂 I also loved the snorkeling because the water in Grand Cayman was the clearest blue I have ever seen…but you probably already know that since you went scuba diving. My husband also really liked the turtle farm on the island tour. You get to see huge sea turtles and hold baby ones. I think you can also swim with them but we didn’t have time. There was also a place where you could swim with the dolphins across the street from the turtle farm. Oh, and you might as well check out the little town called “Hell” just to say you’ve been there… I got a kick out of sending a postcard back home postmarked from Hell 🙂 And stock up on rum cakes…YUM! Well this was a long response but I just really loved the Cayman Islands, lol. Enjoy the rest of your vacation!!!

  6. Amy says:

    Happy Anniversary!!! You look SO beautiful in your wedding photos…and your photographer did a great job! What great colors/light/shadow in all the shots. On another note, these bars look crazy good. I would never have thought to use anything besides another type of cereal in a rice krispie treat knock-off. Yum!

  7. That is so fun to be able to visit the place where you got married again. Your wedding looks like it was wonderful. Have fun reminiscing down there!

  8. wow, sweet pea – you were such a beautiful bride!! happy wedding anniversary!!!

  9. Michelle says:

    I love the pictures of your wedding! I hope you’re enjoying your anniversary in Grand Cayman 🙂

    PS… the bars look awesome and so easy to make!

  10. briarrose says:

    Happy anniversary! Beautiful photos. It looks like it was a fabulous ceremony. 🙂

  11. Caroline says:

    Happy 3rd anniversary, Christina! Thanks for sharing these photos, they’re all absolutely gorgeous. And your dress was stunning! I definitely understand why you got married here, and are visiting again.

  12. Your wedding cake sounds DELICIOUS, rum cake and coconut cream filling, swoon. Happy Anniversary! Im pretty pumped for some hot weather so I can justify making tons of no bake desserts!

  13. The Teenage Taste says:

    Happy Anniversary, Christina! Thanks for posting the wedding picture. You were a beautiful bride! 😀

  14. Carol Armour says:

    We have been timeshare owners there since 1985. One restaurant our family and friends all agree is a must do is called “Calypso Grill.” It can be difficult to get in there at times but well worth it. Also check out the beautiful tile work in the observation deck at Camana Bay.

    • Christina says:

      We went to Calypso Grill for dinner last night and it was amazing! 🙂 I ordered the Jamaican Jerk Curry Jumbo Shrimp and my husband ordered the Mahi Mahi Escoveitch. We sat outside on the deck overlooking Morgan’s Harbour and watched a pretty awesome lighting storm in the distance over the ocean. We absolutely loved it and the setting was perfect! 🙂

  15. Gorrrrrrgeous pics!! Happy Anniversary. And I’m making those bars PRONTO!! Sooo right up my alley. XOXO

  16. Lucie says:

    Beautiful photos! Congratulations on your anniversary!

  17. AmyS, Cedar Rapids, IA says:

    I have been following your blog since last November when I made the pumpkin fudge. I have made many of these recipes since. But, I have to say…I was nervous about this recipe when I was at the point of mixing the three ingredients together. The texture is so weird! But, I have to say…they turned out just like yours and were a huge success at work yesterday! Thanks for your many interesting recipes!

    • Christina says:

      I am so glad that you and your co-workers enjoyed these bars. I was a bit nervous as well when I first made them…the texture is very different! But the final product was delicious and sooo super easy to make! 😀

  18. Pingback: Oreo Rice Krispies….without the Krispies!! « Jackatessa's Blog

  19. Pingback: Crunchy Peanut Butter Dog Treats | Sweet Pea's Kitchen

  20. Your pictures are beautiful! I’m thinking that this bar is a good, easy replacement for the day-to-day taste of a rice krispie bar! They look delicious….do they taste like an Oreo truffle?

    • Christina says:

      They are really good…they don’t really taste like a truffle just because there is no cream cheese in them. Kinda like a rice krispie treat but Oreo flavored. 🙂

  21. Kara says:

    I made these a few weeks ago, they were super good. I will be postin about them this week. Thanks!

  22. Pingback: Oreo Bars | livelovepasta

  23. Those look amazing! I love how simple the ingredients are. YUM!

  24. Pingback: S’mores Bars | chocolate & carrots

  25. Pingback: No Bake Cookies & Cream Bars | keeping the dreams alive

  26. Pingback: On Pins and…Oreos « Go With the Dough

  27. Pingback: Ceviche with Mango and Avocado | Sweet Pea's Kitchen

  28. Pingback: Seven Links | Sweet Pea's Kitchen

  29. Pingback: Grilled Vegetable Couscous with Lemon and Goat Cheese | Sweet Pea's Kitchen

  30. Myrynda Freeman says:

    LOVE THESE! I had mixed feelings on the texture but I absolutely loved them. They are very chewy and just have an all around great flavor,thanks for sharing!

  31. Hello. I think I am missing something. There are 3 ingredients. Ground oreos, marshmallows and butter. You say that they taste like an oreo flavored rice krispie type treat, yet I do not see the Rice Krispie in the ingredients?

    • Christina says:

      Nope you aren’t missing anything! 🙂 Only three ingredients are needed! They remind me of rice krispie treats because they have the same texture and consistency, but there are no rice krispies in the recipe.

  32. Thanks so much. I MUST try these. I will let you know how it goes 🙂

  33. Happy Anniversary…Very beautiful wedding.

    I know I am going to have t try these treats…

  34. Cubette says:

    hey, could you use 5 cups marshmallow cream instead of marshmallows?

    • Christina says:

      I have never tried this recipe using marshmallow crème. Since they are very similar to rice krispie treats and marshmallow crème can be used to make those, I am sure these would turn out great! If you end up trying these with marshmallow crème I would love to hear how they turn out! 🙂

  35. georgina says:

    Hi, first-time visitor, here.

    Is it necessary to butter both the pan and paper? Does the butter leave a residue on the outer-bars?
    Also, how many does this make? I don’t know how thick this would be in an 8×8.

  36. kat says:

    yum! what a great idea!!

  37. Mindy McCamish says:

    If I could live anywhere in the world, it would be Grand Caymans.

    Made these bars for our Thanksgiving dinner at church. I needed an easy, quick dessert that could be easily portioned for a mad rush. These look crazy when you are making them, but they are super yummy. Will use this recipe again! Thank you!

  38. Lily says:

    Oh these sound good and so easy! Thanks for the idea!

  39. snw219 says:

    those sound wonderful – i’m also imagining them with rice krispies added, too.

  40. Mollie says:

    I saw these on Pinterest and just made them. They are DEeelish! I highly suggest liberally buttering the wax paper though. They are sticky little suckers!

  41. Amber says:

    Theses are freaking amazing!!!!!!

  42. Pingback: Homemade Holidays DIY Gift Guide: Sweet and Savory Food Gifts | Ginger(ly) Homemaking

  43. Pingback: The Complete Homemade Holidays DIY Gift Guide Roundup | Ginger(ly) Homemaking

  44. Pingback: Much to Catch Up On! « Food, Faith, and Other Fabulous Finds

  45. Bex says:

    These look great, do you think they would be ok sitting out overnight (covered) or should they be refrigerated? I’m goin to make them for a bridal shower an was wondering if I can make them the day before.

    • Christina says:

      You can definitely make these the day before. I would keep them in an airtight container at room temperature. If you give them a try I would love to hear how they turn out! 🙂

  46. Ginger says:

    I think I am missing something – your directions say to press the rice mixture into the pan, but I don’t see “rice” anything in the ingredients??

  47. Susie says:

    LOVE these and beautiful wedding photos!! Stop in and link them up in my Happy 100th Birthday Party for Oreo! I’d be honored to have your recipe attend the party!

    If you have anything else Oreo, feel free to link up! I”m promoting the party like crazy 🙂


  48. Michelle says:

    I think that these would be GREAT as a stocking stuffer (lump of coal) for Christmas! I can’t wait to try them out.

  49. Pingback: Favorite Food Friday—via Pinterest ! | - Sharing ideas on thrifting, organizing, decorating, crafting and cooking on a budget

  50. Theresa says:

    Found some gluten free “oreo type” cookies. Can’t wait to make this for my daughter! I will of course, have to sample them too! 🙂

  51. Pingback: Oh, How Pinteresting – Pins I’ve Actually Done | Uberly Ecstatic

  52. Cindy Carter says:

    Hi Christina,
    Next time you are ‘on island’ take a trip over to the east end…collier bay. We stay at Morritts Grand every year….GREAT diving options along north and east walls. If you get over to the east end, try TUKKA…used to be Portifino, which was terrific, but Tukka has surpassed that experiance. Another local fave is Over the Edge on the way to Rum Point…..very reasonable prices and you may see your dive captains there! Rum Point is not to be missed either. If you are hooked on 7 mile beach, but like more solitude….rent a car and spend the day on the other side!

  53. Patty Smith says:

    We have been to Grand Caymen several times and seven mile beach is gorgeous. One of our favorite things to do is to go to stingray city with Moby Dick tours. Their staff is so great. And the reef they take you to snorkeling is so beautiful. We enjoy going to Margarittaville of course but Rack Ems is a great treat with reasonable prices and a great view.

  54. Tori says:

    the bars are delicious! only thing i would suggest is making them on the stove instead of in the microwave. my experience was that the marshmallows cooled down too quickly and it was really difficult to mix in the oreos. next time i will try mixing them on the stovetop.

  55. Pingback: German Chocolate Brownies for Our 4th Wedding Anniversary | Sweet Pea's Kitchen

  56. Pingback: Blueberry Lemonade | Sweet Pea's Kitchen

  57. Becky says:

    Cinfratulations and Happy Anniversary! I have been going to Grand Cayman for 28 years. It is such a great island and I always feel “home” when I get there. The pistachio crusted sea bass at the Wharf is to die for! Also, if you like lobster- Deckers does an all you can eat lobster that hubby always takes advantage of. The Lighthouse is a bit of a drive, but the food is excellent. IMO- you can’t go wrong on a snorkel trip with Captain Clinton. He is wonderful! Pedro’s Castle is fun and very interesting. Have a great time! Seeing your pictures makes me so excited to be going back in Dec. Enjoy!

  58. Athina says:

    Just thought I’d mention that I saw the recipe for the Oreo bake on Pinterest, made it, and my friends and I LOVE them! They’re so good, thank you!

  59. Amber | Bluebonnets & Brownies says:

    I just saw these via Pinterest, clicked over, and was so happy to see your beautiful wedding photos! I can’t wait to make this recipe.

  60. Pingback: Project Pinterest – No Bake Cookies and Cream Bars « bakinginmybathingsuit

  61. Balvinder says:

    Congrats on three years of happy married life and many more to come. I haven’t seen such no bake bars before.

  62. Mary says:

    Those of you who have been to Grand Cayman recently — is the Cool Spot still open? It’s a down home spot where I first ate goat(curried and amazingly good). Very rustic, very Caymanian!

  63. Shelby says:

    I stumbled across this recipe on Pinterest and anfter a couple months, I’m finally making them! However, ironically, I did not know anything about Cayman being in this post when I pinned it, but I am Caymanian! I grew up on Grand Cayman, went so school there, and never stopped loving it as my home! I always love to hear how much other people love it there! Thank you very much!

  64. barbara miller says:

    made these today, 8/15/12, used berry oreos (chocolate cookie and pink berry flavor creme) and strawberry marshmallows. wow it’s good. I melted my butter and marshmallow on top of the stove. I’m gonna try PB Oreo and sub the butter with PB and plain marshmallow. Mint oreo and plain marshmallow. Vanilla oreo and those orange circus peanut candies (they are marshmallows.)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s